Diedrich 370 Posted October 31, 2015 Posted October 31, 2015 I would like to request the ability to shutdown the computer within Emby. This would be the same functionality available through Kodi but for those who do not use Kodi. The reasoning is because I currently have the ability to WOL my HTPC but to shutdown the computer (after viewing on the iPad, for example) I must then startup Teamviewer just to shutdown the computer. If I had the ability to login to my Emby admin account I could then press a button that would send the shutdown.exe command (or corresponding Linux command) and would make everything much more efficient.
Koleckai Silvestri 1151 Posted October 31, 2015 Posted October 31, 2015 Several clients have this capability already. Not sure it makes much sense for the server itself.
Diedrich 370 Posted October 31, 2015 Author Posted October 31, 2015 Several clients have this capability already. Not sure it makes much sense for the server itself.Watching on an iPad (or any web client) does not have the ability to shutdown the system. It makes perfect sense. It doesn't inconvenience anyone to have the function.
Vidman 590 Posted October 31, 2015 Posted October 31, 2015 It would inconvenience anyone watching or listening to something on that server
Diedrich 370 Posted November 1, 2015 Author Posted November 1, 2015 It would inconvenience anyone watching or listening to something on that serverWhich is why in the OP I mentioned making this function a feature for the admin account, i.e. not a standard user. You don't have to click it if you don't want to, but _I_ do.
Koleckai Silvestri 1151 Posted November 1, 2015 Posted November 1, 2015 Watching on an iPad (or any web client) does not have the ability to shutdown the system. It makes perfect sense. It doesn't inconvenience anyone to have the function. Would inconvenience me, especially when a family member gets upset because the latest episode of their favorite series isn't available. I am running other things on the server and expect it to be on and available 24/7.
Diedrich 370 Posted November 1, 2015 Author Posted November 1, 2015 Would inconvenience me, especially when a family member gets upset because the latest episode of their favorite series isn't available. I am running other things on the server and expect it to be on and available 24/7.You misunderstand, it doesn't inconvenience the Emby admin to have this feature. You. Don't. Have. To. Use. it If. You. Don't. Want. to. If you gave all your users admin rights then you're doing it wrong. Only the admin user would have the shutdown button, and if you (as the admin user), don't know when to shutdown the computer or have a compulsion to press said button then you shouldn't be running such powerful software.
ebr 15667 Posted November 1, 2015 Posted November 1, 2015 But what about other systems that may be running on the machine that the Emby admin user may or may not be aware of? I'm just not sure this is something that falls within the purview of our system. There are lots of utilities out there that can allow you to manage the server machine itself remotely. I use Pulseway, for example.
Diedrich 370 Posted November 1, 2015 Author Posted November 1, 2015 I describe it in a different way... A system shutdown button in the Emby Server admin screen would be no different than having direct access to the OS's shutdown function but it would be for users who do not have direct access to their computer's OS. It saves a step to not have to deal with 3rd party programs for OS control.
Diedrich 370 Posted November 1, 2015 Author Posted November 1, 2015 I use Pulseway, for example.Never heard of it but just looked into it, it looks nice. However, you are adding yet another piece of software to your OS when the same shutdown function can be utilized within Emby. What if Pulseway stops maintaining their app? What if the phone app becomes obsolete on your phone's OS?
Deathsquirrel 744 Posted November 2, 2015 Posted November 2, 2015 Never heard of it but just looked into it, it looks nice. However, you are adding yet another piece of software to your OS when the same shutdown function can be utilized within Emby. What if Pulseway stops maintaining their app? What if the phone app becomes obsolete on your phone's OS? The use RDP, VNC, whatever. There are a bizillion remote access apps.
ebr 15667 Posted November 2, 2015 Posted November 2, 2015 I describe it in a different way... A system shutdown button in the Emby Server admin screen would be no different than having direct access to the OS's shutdown function but it would be for users who do not have direct access to their computer's OS. It saves a step to not have to deal with 3rd party programs for OS control. But the assumption there is that the Emby Administrator is also the machine administrator and I don't know that that is an assumption we want to make. Direct machine operations just seem outside the scope of what we need to be putting in the system. They are there on a limited basis in some clients because you are dealing with an HTPC or end device that is thought of as more of an appliance.
george 0 Posted November 2, 2015 Posted November 2, 2015 There are a lot of apps that we can remotely login to the server but a sleep button in the GUI of the web client would be very convince instead of going back to the computer using VNC to login and putting the server to sleep. Also on top of that A wake up button would be even better in order the web client to send a magic packet to wake up the server. Of course for the routers that support forwarding magic packets from the internet
Filosteel 2 Posted June 17, 2024 Posted June 17, 2024 Hey, sorry if I started a new thread on the same topic. Search for "turn off computer" and "shut down computer" didn't return anything, but I see it's all one-word "shutdown". I think it would be very nice to have this feature. Steam Link has this, so I can shut down my computer after playing games in the living room; I find it super useful. I am not sure I understand the pushback regarding Emby Admin possibly not being the machine admin. Given Emby is developed for personal media, I would wager the vast majority of users are private individuals with a film collection, so the Emby admin would likely be the machine admin. Even if this is not true, and there cases where, say, somebody else in the family sets up Emby on a shared computer, it can be assumed people in a family (or in general, people on a shared computer) talk to each other, and they should know if the computer should never be turned off or if tere are other tings going on (e.g. somebody else in the family is watching a movie, too). I guess that's the same spirit Steam Link works with. There could be an option on the Emby server to disable this for all users, so the Admin can decide. There could also be an option of selecting "don't ask me again" and save a user preferences. I think this could be useful on the "non-mobile" apps. Meaning Linux/Win/Android/Android TV. Possibly also the tablet, but not sure. This due to the reasoning that people watching movies on a mobile are likely on the road/travelling (otherwise they would be completely unhinged to use a phone if a better screen is available), so they will likely don't need to turn the computer off (unless a wake signal can also be sent to reactivate it) as they will want to watch more movies during the rest of the trip. These are my thoughts as of now, after having forgotten to turn off the computer 3 or 4 times after the movie ended But it's by no means a critical feature, I just thought it would have been useful since I use this option on Steam Link literally every time. 1
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now