jglazer63 25 Posted Thursday at 05:34 PM Posted Thursday at 05:34 PM Hah, knew that would make you look... ...but it is kinda true. I share my Emby media library with my 80 year old sister. She has recently discovered that she enjoys watching her shows through a Bluetooth headset that she can crank up to hear better. Yep, you know what's coming..... She constantly complains that the audio (specifically dialog) does not sync with the video. She grimaces and continues to watch but I can understand the discomfort. There has got to be some way to adjust the audio timing. I know this has been in the back-burner for years but now I am seeing it in a slightly different light. Sorta senior discrimination. So once again, I am hoping this adds a bit more fuel to this feature request. Thanks for tolerating my rant!
pwhodges 2133 Posted Thursday at 05:45 PM Posted Thursday at 05:45 PM What Bluetooth standard does her headset and the transmitter it's connecting to support? Older standards have appreciable delay, but the latest are fine. My wife is deaf, and has Bluetooth in her hearing aids, and there is a Bluetooth transmitter from the hearing aid company behind the TV (using the optical output) - that syncs fine. I use four-year-old Sony headphones connecting to my iPad, and there is no sync problem there either (I'm also 80, but I guess that's not really relevant). However, I agree that an adjustment is useful, because a significant number of videos and broadcasts have poor timing anyway. Paul
jglazer63 25 Posted Thursday at 06:10 PM Author Posted Thursday at 06:10 PM She is using Air pods and a Sony TV that has Bluetooth. She tells me it is only Emby that has issues as she can watch cable TV without a hitch. Not sure how that can be but I cannot argue without going there and trying it.
Amything 151 Posted Thursday at 07:00 PM Posted Thursday at 07:00 PM Ha! I do think Emby is the most user friendly of the popular solutions 1
jglazer63 25 Posted Thursday at 07:57 PM Author Posted Thursday at 07:57 PM 55 minutes ago, Amything said: Ha! I do think Emby is the most user friendly of the popular solutions Not sure how this reply addresses the situation in the least. I think it has a pretty interface too .... now back to the question at hand...???
seanbuff 1453 Posted Thursday at 08:03 PM Posted Thursday at 08:03 PM 1 hour ago, jglazer63 said: She is using Air pods and a Sony TV that has Bluetooth. Which Emby app is she using on the Sony TV, and have you tested with both the Android TV app and the standard Android app?
ebr 17052 Posted Thursday at 08:57 PM Posted Thursday at 08:57 PM Also investigate whether the TV itself has any BT related settings for this.
Gilgamesh_48 1259 Posted Thursday at 11:12 PM Posted Thursday at 11:12 PM I am 79, so not too far behind your 80 year old sister. I discovered, quite a while ago, that Emby, in some situations, did not sync audio perfectly and this was exacerbated by the use of any wireless headphone technology. The symptoms were not always exactly what you describe but they do tend to get irritating at times. My solution was simplicity itself. I stopped using wireless headphones and started using wired exclusively. I know that is not even close to an ideal solution but it is easier than trying to get Emby to fix every environment that is encountered, there are a near infinite number of possible configurations that Emby might be operated in. The only other way I have been able to get Emb to sync near perfectly with wireless headphones has been to use my Shield TV for Emby and use the Shield's internal bluetooth for audio. For some reason my Shield is better than my TV at handling Emby's audio. BTW: I have yet to find a so called "smart TV" that was any good at anything complex. I always connect external devices for Emby and virtually every other function I use. I use either my Shield or my Roku for accessing everything from ESPN to Paramount+ to Pandora. And, in every case, the app is superior to use on my Roku or my Shield that it is on my TV. The separate boxes also have the advantage of, when the TV breaks, being simply an unplug and plug in to the new TV without any additional configuration. But i know that solution is not for everyone it is just what I use and it works quite well for me. Emby is user friendly regardless of the age of the user. I have a neighbor that is 92 and a great grandson of my cousin who just turned 8 and they both just love Emby and have no trouble using it. I, at 79, am even able to maintain my own server as is my 92 year old neighbor. Emby is just about the easiest software i own to use and maintain.
jglazer63 25 Posted Thursday at 11:14 PM Author Posted Thursday at 11:14 PM (edited) 2 minutes ago, Gilgamesh_48 said: I am 79, so not too far behind your 80 year old sister. I discovered, quite a while ago, that Emby, in some situations, did not sync audio perfectly and this was exacerbated by the use of any wireless headphone technology. The symptoms were not always exactly what you describe but they do tend to get irritating at times. My solution was simplicity itself. I stopped using wireless headphones and started using wired exclusively. I know that is not even close to an ideal solution but it is easier than trying to get Emby to fix every environment that is encountered, there are a near infinite number of possible configurations that Emby might be operated in. The only other way I have been able to get Emb to sync near perfectly with wireless headphones has been to use my Shield TV for Emby and use the Shield's internal bluetooth for audio. For some reason my Shield is better than my TV at handling Emby's audio. BTW: I have yet to find a so called "smart TV" that was any good at anything complex. I always connect external devices for Emby and virtually every other function I use. I use either my Shield or my Roku for accessing everything from ESPN to Paramount+ to Pandora. And, in every case, the app is superior to use on my Roku or my Shield that it is on my TV. The separate boxes also have the advantage of, when the TV breaks, being simply an unplug and plug in to the new TV without any additional configuration. But i know that solution is not for everyone it is just what I use and it works quite well for me. Emby is user friendly regardless of the age of the user. I have a neighbor that is 92 and a great grandson of my cousin who just turned 8 and they both just love Emby and have no trouble using it. I, at 79, am even able to maintain my own server as is my 92 year old neighbor. Emby is just about the easiest software i own to use and maintain. Never said Emby wasn't user friendly. Just have issues with the audio as described. Edited Thursday at 11:15 PM by jglazer63 1
jglazer63 25 Posted Thursday at 11:15 PM Author Posted Thursday at 11:15 PM 2 hours ago, ebr said: Also investigate whether the TV itself has any BT related settings for this. I do not think it does and it would probably be beyond her to use em.
Luke 43588 Posted Thursday at 11:17 PM Posted Thursday at 11:17 PM Hi, so it would be user friendly if there was no audio sync problem ?
jglazer63 25 Posted Thursday at 11:18 PM Author Posted Thursday at 11:18 PM Just now, Luke said: Hi, so it would be user friendly if there was no audio sync problem ? Never said Emby wasn't user friendly. Just have issues with the audio as described.
Luke 43588 Posted Thursday at 11:27 PM Posted Thursday at 11:27 PM So it would be senior friendly of it weren’t for that?
Gilgamesh_48 1259 Posted Thursday at 11:33 PM Posted Thursday at 11:33 PM 10 minutes ago, jglazer63 said: Never said Emby wasn't user friendly. Just have issues with the audio as described. Actually you did say it was not senior friendly and that means it is not friendly to some users. I pointed out that people i know have no trouble using it and I offered a couple of possible solutions. BTW: I doubt that it is only Emby that exhibits the problem. The first thing I would try is an external box like a Roku as they are very cheap. A Fire Stick is also a possibility but I simply do not like the Fier devices very much. Of course the wired headphones are a 100% solution. They are just not as elegant.
js28194 79 Posted Friday at 01:59 AM Posted Friday at 01:59 AM (edited) That is interesting.... So I'll share with you my solution. I use Kodi4Emby plugin and Kodi (so not true native Emby app) on a Nvidia Shield device as my daily driver with these cheap headsets so I can fall asleep in comfortably. I will do some testing with pure Emby when I get back. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0FPFSBZBM?th=1 @jglazer63Just a friendly request... your title won't allow others who search for this issue discover this thread easily please consider modifying it so others can participate in the future. I understand if you don't. Edited Friday at 02:29 AM by js28194
ebr 17052 Posted Friday at 03:06 PM Posted Friday at 03:06 PM I have renamed the thread so it is more clear what is being discussed. Thanks. 1
rbjtech 5415 Posted 2 hours ago Posted 2 hours ago (edited) @jglazer63 The OP just wants some suggestions on how to fix the BT audio lag which depending on his setup, is pretty common but is very unlikely anything to do with emby. #1 - Is to ensure you are getting the audio source from the original client device (assuming it transits a bluetooth signal). For example - if I had a Nvidia Shield connected to a TV - I would ideally use the Nvidia Shield to connect my headphones to, rather than the TV - because they may introduce lag. #2 - Use modern BT technologies that reduce/eliminate lag - aptx etc Any BT headphones in the last 3-4 years should have all this built in. I use BT headphones all the time, just cheap Sony WF-C510 in-ears for the complete freedom and hear zero lag from my Shield out the box (or if I switch sources, my TV or AV ) Edited 1 hour ago by rbjtech 1
jglazer63 25 Posted 1 hour ago Author Posted 1 hour ago 56 minutes ago, rbjtech said: @jglazer63 The OP just wants some suggestions on how to fix the BT audio lag which depending on his setup, is pretty common but is very unlikely anything to do with emby. #1 - Is to ensure you are getting the audio source from the original client device (assuming it transits a bluetooth signal). For example - if I had a Nvidia Shield connected to a TV - I would ideally use the Nvidia Shield to connect my headphones to, rather than the TV - because they may introduce lag. #2 - Use modern BT technologies that reduce/eliminate lag - aptx etc Any BT headphones in the last 3-4 years should have all this built in. I use BT headphones all the time, just cheap Sony WF-C510 in-ears for the complete freedom and hear zero lag from my Shield out the box (or if I switch sources, my TV or AV ) She is using modern airpods. I haven't had a chance to go out there but it has been a complaint for a while with her. Hopefully I don't have to buy her a new TV to fix this.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now