Jump to content

Confirmation needed - TV - internal app (emby) LG won't passthrough TrueHD


Go to solution Solved by ebr,

Recommended Posts

gator99
Posted

After fighting with this for a while I think I have searched enough and would just like a confirmation on what I have read on this forum and other (AVS etc).

A while ago changed from a projector  to a 98" TV (TCL 98Q672G) and like the simplicity of the setup and previously had used a shield 2017 for everything.

But discovered that with the TV's Emby app could not get Atmos to play - so after cable upgrades and a new AVR with 2.1 eArc (Onkyo RZ-30) - still couldn't get Atmos from tv to receiver - though shield does work, server says that it is "Direct Play" for audio (TrueHD 7.1) and video for both TV and Shield.

So I was under the impression that with 2.1 HDMI (cables, TV HDMI and receiver) that eArc would pass Atmos (passthrough setup on TV etc).

Guess I was ill informed. - so thought I would get confirmation and accept that if I want Atmos from Emby that I have to use the Shield - which I really wanted to get away from.

Thanks in Advance.

  • Solution
Posted

Hi.  Atmos isn't your problem. The issue is the TV probably doesn't support the underlying format of TrueHD - especially in 7.1.  A DD+ track with Atmos will probably work just fine.

 

gator99
Posted
9 minutes ago, ebr said:

Hi.  Atmos isn't your problem. The issue is the TV probably doesn't support the underlying format of TrueHD - especially in 7.1.  A DD+ track with Atmos will probably work just fine.

 

thanks, sorry meant to say that streaming serivces with DD+ Atmos work,  so my understanding of passthrough on the TV is incorrect then and the TV will not pass the TrueHD 7.1 Atmos track through eArc to the Receiver - if that is the case I guess nothing I can do.

Thanks again, just trying to make sure I am ruling out everything before I give up on the TV's internal app - everything else on TV to receiver works great.

Neminem
Posted

With Tdarr or handbreak you can downscale 7.1 to 5.1 and leave the old audio stream as is.

Creating a new 5.1 to be used.

Then you can chose 5.1 when you need to.

gator99
Posted
2 minutes ago, Neminem said:

With Tdarr or handbreak you can downscale 7.1 to 5.1 and leave the old audio stream as is.

Creating a new 5.1 to be used.

Then you can chose 5.1 when you need to.

Thank you for the reply, I have both 7.1 and 5.1 streams so I can switch between 2, just would love the Atmos.

Thanks again for the info.

Sammy
Posted (edited)
7 hours ago, Neminem said:

With Tdarr or handbreak you can downscale 7.1 to 5.1 and leave the old audio stream as is.

Creating a new 5.1 to be used.

Then you can chose 5.1 when you need to.

Tdarr is a new one on me. Is it better than handbrake (which I haven't had to use in years BTW)?

Edited by Sammy
Sammy
Posted

Atmos is just a height channel. My Denon will add height to a stream without it.

justinrh
Posted

Connect the Shield to the sound bar/receiver and use its pass thru to get the video to the TV.

  • Like 1
gator99
Posted
11 hours ago, Luke said:

@gator99has this helped?

Luke it has EBR, confirmed that the internal apps cannot pass true hd, though they do pas DTS 6.1 MA

Posted
14 hours ago, gator99 said:

Luke it has EBR, confirmed that the internal apps cannot pass true hd, though they do pas DTS 6.1 MA

Hi, no that's not what he said:

Quote

The issue is the TV probably doesn't support the underlying format of TrueHD

 

gator99
Posted

Thanks for the clarification 

Posted

Yeah, I hypothesized that but you'll need to confirm if that is actually the case.  I think it probably is because, at this time, I think only the LG OLEDs support passing TrueHD via eARC.

  • 9 months later...
SaiTatter
Posted (edited)

As many of you probably know, most Android/Google TVs do not support Dolby TrueHD Atmos passthrough from internal applications such as Kodi, Plex or Jellyfin, even though they can successfully pass the same audio format from an external HDMI source to an eARC-compatible soundbar or AV receiver.

A few days ago, I started reverse-engineering the TCL audio firmware to investigate whether this limitation could be removed.

My current testing setup:

- TV: TCL 65C9K

- Firmware: V670

- Operating system: Google TV / Android 14

- Soundbar: TCL Q85H Pro

 

What I've discovered so far:

- Dolby Digital Plus Atmos works correctly from internal applications.

- Dolby TrueHD Atmos works correctly from external HDMI sources.

- TrueHD playback from internal applications loses the Atmos metadata.

- Several restrictions appear to be implemented within the vendor audio libraries and audio HAL.

- A particularly promising finding is a flag called `MatMlpOnly`, which appears to behave differently depending on whether the audio originates from an internal application or an external HDMI source.

 

This suggests that the limitation may be related to software or firmware rather than an inherent hardware constraint. However, further testing is needed to confirm this.

I've created a public GitHub repository where I'm documenting my findings, diagnostic tools, reverse-engineering experiments and potential solutions:

https://github.com/saitatter/tcl-earc-passthrough-research

My next step is to obtain root access to my TV so that I can experiment with targeted modifications to the vendor audio components.

I'm currently waiting for some hardware to arrive so that I can investigate the ESP32/UART approach through the HDMI service interface documented in this repository:

https://github.com/lukasa1993/tcl-tv-toolkit

If successful, the ultimate goal would be to enable lossless Dolby TrueHD Atmos passthrough directly from internal applications, without requiring an external media player such as an NVIDIA Shield.

I'd really appreciate any help from people with experience in TCL firmware, MediaTek platforms, Android audio HALs, embedded Linux or reverse engineering. I'm also particularly interested in hearing from anyone who has successfully rooted a TCL TV running firmware V670.

It's frustrating to have hardware capable of handling these audio formats while software limitations prevent us from fully utilising it.

Hopefully, we can work together to find a solution that benefits the wider TCL community.

I'll keep this thread updated as the investigation progresses!

Edited by SaiTatter
Posted
5 hours ago, SaiTatter said:

This suggests that the limitation may be related to software or firmware rather than an inherent hardware constraint.

Hi.  The constraint is financial.  Dolby is a business.  It isn't in business to provide free software as it then would not be in business :).  TV manufacturers, therefore, have to pay Dolby for supporting certain formats.  If they don't, they don't get to support the format.

What you are doing (reverse-engineering the firmware) I'm almost sure will be expressly against the terms of use of your TV.  However, for your personal use, that's not really any big deal.  What you don't want to do is publish some method of circumventing these restrictions for anyone else.

Just FYI...

SaiTatter
Posted (edited)
3 hours ago, ebr said:

Hi.  The constraint is financial.  Dolby is a business.  It isn't in business to provide free software as it then would not be in business :).  TV manufacturers, therefore, have to pay Dolby for supporting certain formats.  If they don't, they don't get to support the format.

What you are doing (reverse-engineering the firmware) I'm almost sure will be expressly against the terms of use of your TV.  However, for your personal use, that's not really any big deal.  What you don't want to do is publish some method of circumventing these restrictions for anyone else.

Just FYI...

I totally understand you, but what should be also illegal is buying a TV for features that are not clearly stated to the consumer and for it's TOS to be needed to be accepted after buying the TV. It literally make zero sense to block redirecting truehd from internal apps when it can redirect it from HDMI. I'm not even sure this is a licensing issue, since I don't know any TV that can passtrough truehd from internal apps and instead it downgrades it to 5.1 dd+. If we continue to accept this as consumers we'll end up having to pay for the air we breathe.

Edited by SaiTatter
Posted
39 minutes ago, SaiTatter said:

It literally make zero sense to block redirecting truehd from internal apps when it can redirect it from HDMI

This isn't my game but, that actually does make sense.  The licensing has been paid by the device sending it through the HDMI chain so it isn't required again by the TV to just be a pass through channel.  That would make no sense...

Posted
40 minutes ago, SaiTatter said:

since I don't know any TV that can passtrough truehd from internal apps and instead it downgrades it to 5.1 dd+

That's because the source of 99% of the content the TV can consume (streaming providers) doesn't contain TrueHD so it makes no sense for them to pay for it.

yocker
Posted
6 hours ago, ebr said:

Hi.  The constraint is financial.  Dolby is a business.  It isn't in business to provide free software as it then would not be in business :).  TV manufacturers, therefore, have to pay Dolby for supporting certain formats.  If they don't, they don't get to support the format.

What you are doing (reverse-engineering the firmware) I'm almost sure will be expressly against the terms of use of your TV.  However, for your personal use, that's not really any big deal.  What you don't want to do is publish some method of circumventing these restrictions for anyone else.

Just FYI...

In the EU that can actually be legal as people own the product they bought, not as in the US where you effectively buy a license to use it.
It IS a legal grey area as it has never been challenged in any court though but as long as no copyrighted software is exchanged it should not be a problem.

I know people have been legally unlocking paid options like heated seats (really BMW?!?) because they bought the car and thus own it.

SaiTatter
Posted (edited)
30 minutes ago, yocker said:

In the EU that can actually be legal as people own the product they bought, not as in the US where you effectively buy a license to use it.
It IS a legal grey area as it has never been challenged in any court though but as long as no copyrighted software is exchanged it should not be a problem.

I know people have been legally unlocking paid options like heated seats (really BMW?!?) because they bought the car and thus own it.

Exactly; I won't distribute their libraries whatsoever, but I will happily distribute the code that can patch them and allow us our rights. Of course if this is even possible in the first place, I still have some components to get to be able to try the root. And if it's needed we can even start a petition .I heard there are already some movements going on regarding the bloatware and spyware (looking at you LG) distributed with the tvs software.

Edited by SaiTatter
yocker
Posted (edited)
5 minutes ago, SaiTatter said:

Exactly; I won't distribute their libraries whatsoever, but I will happily distribute the code that can patch them and allow us our rights. Of course if this is even possible in the first place, I still have some components to get to be able to try the root.

Do note i said it "CAN" be legal in the EU!
Breaking any lock at all is illegal in the US.

I just don't want to be the cause of trouble. ;) 

 

Edited by yocker
SaiTatter
Posted
5 minutes ago, yocker said:

Do note i said it "CAN" be legal in the EU!
Breaking any lock at all is illegal in the US.

I just don't want to be the cause of trouble. ;) 

 

Definitely, I know that most copyrights and stuff like this regarding software is very gray area, and legislation is moving way too slow.

SaiTatter
Posted (edited)
24 minutes ago, yocker said:

Do note i said it "CAN" be legal in the EU!
Breaking any lock at all is illegal in the US.

I just don't want to be the cause of trouble. ;) 

 

"I just don't want to be the cause of trouble." Yeah, don't worry mate and thanks so much for the thoughts. I'm trying to keep it as little illegal as possible as it can be, but as any hack it's debatable since it involves reverse engineering. I really hope that movement will grow bigger and at least allow users to reverse engineer any device software they use if that involves removing spyware, improving it or fixing it. In this case it may be very well an intentional blocker, but there's so many instances where the software is bugged and companies will only support it for a limited time, and very often not even fix it completely. Even in those cases the legislation doesn't cover and reverse engineering it is still illegal which I pretty much disagree with this. And for the love of god devices should come rooted by default or at least allow users to root them easily without having to rely on security exploits.

Edited by SaiTatter
yocker
Posted
3 hours ago, SaiTatter said:

"I just don't want to be the cause of trouble." Yeah, don't worry mate and thanks so much for the thoughts. I'm trying to keep it as little illegal as possible as it can be, but as any hack it's debatable since it involves reverse engineering. I really hope that movement will grow bigger and at least allow users to reverse engineer any device software they use if that involves removing spyware, improving it or fixing it. In this case it may be very well an intentional blocker, but there's so many instances where the software is bugged and companies will only support it for a limited time, and very often not even fix it completely. Even in those cases the legislation doesn't cover and reverse engineering it is still illegal which I pretty much disagree with this. And for the love of god devices should come rooted by default or at least allow users to root them easily without having to rely on security exploits.

Reverse engineering is legal, the PC industry wouldn't be where it is today if other companies didn't reverse engineer IBMs BIOS/firmware and made their own.
As said, just be sure to not reuse any of other peoples code without permission.

Looking forwards to what your project becomes.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...