Jump to content

Custom Convert loses subtitles, but predefined Profile keeps them


Recommended Posts

BrandonYoung
Posted

After recording a Live TV show, I convert the show using the custom profile using the following settings

Container: "mkv"

Video codec: "hevc,h264" 

Audio codec "aac"

Quality: "Original quality"

the resulting file is missing the subtitles.

However, when using the "TV" profile, the resulting file preserves the closed caption subtitles. 

I think the Custom profile should preserve the closed caption subtitles.

Before custom convert

Before_Custom_ConversionKTLA5.thumb.png.7a897783d3bae09cb3313ba0415df4da.png

 

After custom conversion

After_Custom_Conversion_KTLA5.thumb.png.5fc85658514b0dc38c7b059236f623e3.png

Before TV convert

Before_TV_Conversion_ABC7.thumb.png.7f3e483357001b624266316998fc9363.png

After TV Profile conversion

After_TV_Profile_Conversion.thumb.png.e5079d7f8b6b1f75a9bd88efad103881.png

Here is the log file for the Custom transcode ffmpeg-remux-ebd1c42a-f8a3-435b-ad22-a431ba1283ec_1.txt

Here is the log for the TV profile transcode ffmpeg-transcode-319fbb3d-e0e9-408c-9659-ed00f2da52e3_1.txt

The conversions happened after 6:30  when the news programs ended.

Posted

HI, as a test, do you have an h264 source with closed captions that you can test to compare with?

I have a feeling that this is isolated to hevc. Thanks.

BrandonYoung
Posted

 

Here is another recording on the same hevc channel, I converted  using the TV preset, and it converted to h.264 and aac, and kept the closed captions. 

image.thumb.png.eec56594a0d9d42a47b88c934d79df9e.png

Here is the log for the  HEVC TV profile transcode: ffmpeg-transcode-ec32a3b3-814e-428b-b0da-d90a8bada96b_1.txt

I only have a couple of channels with  h.264.  The custom conversion of H.264 to H.264 worked and subtitles were preserved.

H264CustomConversion.thumb.png.9fa28a8c0f940926314846d0e175d143.png

Log for the H.264 to H.264 custom conversion ffmpeg-remux-ebd95160-e16b-418e-a1dc-7a706defe444_1.txt

Posted

OK so that confirms it. We'll look into it. Thanks.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...